English Learners News in Brief

U.S. and Arizona Settle English-Learner Dispute

By The Associated Press — September 11, 2012 1 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. departments of Justice and Education have reached an agreement with the Arizona education department over the state’s rush to move students out of its program for English-language learners.

The federal government said the Aug. 31 settlement requires the state to offer special instruction for tens of thousands of students who were prematurely identified as fluent in English and moved out of the ell program, but state officials disputed that.

The federal government had alleged that the moves violated the students’ civil rights.

“All students are entitled to equal opportunities, and this resolution will help to make sure Arizona students receive the education they deserve,” said a statement from Russlynn Ali, the assistant secretary of the office for civil rights at the federal Education Department.

The settlement between Arizona and the federal government is the latest in the past two years that overturns changes to the program initiated by current Arizona Attorney General Tom Horne when he led the state education department. A separate federal complaint alleging the state inadequately screened students for their need for special language classes was settled last year.

Mr. Horne did not immediately return calls seeking comment.

Two federal investigations completed in 2010 found that Arizona was violating the civil rights of some students who are not native English-speakers by denying them access to special language programs for English-learners.

The state denied that it had violated students’ rights, but settled to conclude the matter, according to the Justice Department.

About 42,000 students are affected by the agreement. Those who failed their most recent state reading and writing assessments will be reviewed and offered extra instruction in English if needed.

Arizona could have lost millions of dollars in federal funding if it didn’t change the system to address investigators’ concerns.

The agreement requires the state to develop new ways to identify ell students and to determine their exit from the program.

A version of this article appeared in the September 12, 2012 edition of Education Week as U.S. and Arizona Settle English-Learner Dispute

Events

College & Workforce Readiness Webinar Data-Driven and District-Ready: What EdWeek Research Tells Us About the CTE Market
Discover how to sharpen your positioning in a fast-moving market of CTE with actionable strategies grounded in EdWeek Research Center data.
Classroom Technology Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: The Rewiring of Childhood With Jonathan Haidt
Jonathan Haidt, Catherine Price, and Adam Swinyard join Peter DeWitt on how to get students off devices and back to the basics of childhood.
Professional Development K-12 Essentials Forum Getting Professional Development to Stick
Join this free virtual event to explore best practices, funding, format, and timing for teacher and principal PD.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

English Learners Making the "Puzzles" of Math Lessons Less Confusing for English Learners
Modeling, pre-teaching, and effective use of visuals can help students, speakers at an EdWeek forum said.
4 min read
ANNANDALE, VA - APRIL 08: English learners are taught the subject, algebra one with ESOL teacher , Anna Kyle, (right)shown here with tenth grader Thinh Vuong Phung and Student teacher Kim Ngo (left) at Annandale High School on April 08, 2026 in Annandale, Virginia. Various approaches include group work, community building, and academic literacy. Materials are created collaboratively, including digital activities (e.g. Kahoot) with writing and speaking assessments. The team tracks progress using standards-based grading and a running spreadsheet. Teachers emphasize vocabulary skills, interactive notebooks, and scaffolds to support language learners. The success of multilingual learners is monitored through test data and reassessments, ensuring students understand their mastery of standards. 
English learners are taught Algebra I by an ESOL teacher at Annandale High School on April 8, 2026 in Annandale, Virginia. English learners in middle and high school are at different places in their language development, which can undermine their confidence and engagement in the subject.
Marvin Joseph for Education Week
English Learners This Simple Procedural Change Can Improve Outcomes for English Learners
A Michigan study found more students exiting out of English-learner status with one policy change.
3 min read
A look at the state of teaching with English learner students in Antioch, Tenn.
A five-year-old English learner works on a rug with other kindergarten students as they talk about the seasons at an elementary school in Antioch, Tenn., on Dec. 3, 2025. A new study found students are more likely to exit out of English-learner status if states partially automate the reclassification process.
William DeShazer for Education Week
English Learners From Our Research Center What Educators Say English Learners Need Most
Educators spoke of the need for more training in a national survey on English-learner instruction.
3 min read
Photo collage of a young English learner student working at his desk. His photo is inside a circle and on a blue background. The blue background is split if 4 quadrants with a subtle brick wall texture. Inside the 4 quadrants are silhouettes of a woman writing on a clipboard, a parent holding the hand of a young girl, a police officer, and two speech bubbles.
Gina Tomko/Education Week + Canva
English Learners From Our Research Center How Schools Serve English Learners Today, in Charts
New national survey data sheds light on where schools can improve English learners' instruction.
4 min read
A look at the state of teaching with English learner students in Antioch, Tenn.
English-language teacher Tameka Marshall leads a lesson dissecting a speech at John F. Kennedy Middle School on Dec. 3, 2025, in Antioch, Tenn. A national survey found that, while English-learner teachers are viewed as primarily responsible for these students, they are not always included in schoolwide instructional decisions.
William DeShazer for Education Week