August 12, 2009
Your article "Challenging Programs Cater to the Profoundly Gifted" (June 10, 2009) highlighted an exemplary gifted-education experience for students ready to begin college in their early teens. But we must not forget that for other advanced students languishing in classrooms across the country, effective gifted programs and services are limited or unavailable.
As higher education faculty members in English and literature departments, we read with concern the list of participants chosen to draft “college ready” standards for the English language arts as part of the common-standards effort coordinated by the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers ("Expert Panels Named in Common-Standards Push," July 1, 2009).
Mike Schmoker raises some interesting points in his online Commentary "Do We Really Need a Longer School Year?" (July 7, 2009). He is correct that we must make the current school day and year more engaging, challenging, and relevant, but his framework is much too narrow.
Michael A. Rebell and Bruce D. Baker’s online Commentary "Assessing 'Success' in School Finance Litigations" (July 8, 2009) grasps at straws to justify unsuccessful court interventions of the past.
Stanley Pogrow deserves praise for seeking new instructional strategies to engage students in high-poverty urban middle and high schools, such as those he outlines in his online Commentary "Boredom in Class? Try 'Outrageous' Instruction" (July 13, 2009). But it’s unlikely that the kind of lessons he describes could be repeated in the typical five-classes-a-day schedule that exists in most public schools in this country. That’s because the energy required to do so would be overwhelming.
As a parent of a special education student, I have my own wish list of what I’d like to see done with the aid recently made available by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act ("Stimulus Tensions Simmer," July 15, 2009).
A quick infusion of funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act will allow many states to continue programs for toddlers and children with disabilities, but the fate of these services beyond next year remains uncertain ("Infant-Toddler Spec. Ed. Program Gets New Life From Stimulus," July 15, 2009).
Patrick F. Bassett, Paul D. Houston, and Rushworth M. Kidder's Commentary "Building Character in Crisis" (July 15, 2009) describes 10 "schools of integrity," independent schools identified for their success in teaching ethics and character. The Character Education Partnership supports the findings outlined by the authors and congratulates these schools for their commitment and leadership.