School Climate & Safety

Student Rights, School Discipline Are at Issue In Off-Campus Dispute

By Mark Walsh — March 20, 1996 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

An off-campus rock-throwing incident in San Marcos, Texas, has turned into an important legal battle over school discipline and the constitutional rights of students.

At issue is a provision in last year’s rewrite of the Texas education code that is designed to keep students suspected of serious off-campus crimes out of regular classrooms.

Nationwide, some school officials have been frustrated to learn they could not prevent students charged with crimes as serious as murder from attending class when the incidents were not school related.

The Texas law provides that “a student shall be removed from class and placed in an alternative education program ... if the student engages in conduct punishable as a felony.”

The law does not require the student to be convicted or even charged with a felony before being removed. It applies if the student has merely been implicated in such a crime.

First Test

Timothy Nevares, a 15-year-old sophomore at San Marcos High School, has become the law’s first legal test. On Jan. 23, Mr. Nevares allegedly threw gravel and rocks at a car and injured a passenger. The driver, who apparently knew Mr. Nevares, reported the incident to police.

Mr. Nevares has not been charged with any crime in connection with the incident, said his lawyer, John Bennett. School officials said they believe the matter is still under review.

Mr. Bennett said Mr. Nevares and a friend were being harassed by the driver of the car as they walked down the street and they threw gravel in self-defense.

A separate Texas law requires police to notify school officials when students are involved in a crime. On Feb. 12, police reported to San Marcos district officials that Mr. Nevares was under investigation for aggravated assault, a felony.

The next day, school officials informed the boy that, as a result, he would be removed from his regular classes and placed in an alternative-education program known as Rebound. The boy’s father, Dan Nevares, sought a hearing on the matter but was told that the law did not authorize one.

The family filed a lawsuit in a state court seeking a temporary injunction and challenging the constitutionality of the law. The school district had the case moved to U.S. District Court in Austin.

On March 1, U.S. District Judge James R. Nowlin granted the plaintiffs’ request for a temporary injunction barring the removal of the boy from his regular classroom. The judge also issued a preliminary ruling on the merits of the case that has worried state officials and school district lawyers.

‘A Form of Punishment’

Judge Nowlin said the Nevareses have a substantial likelihood of winning their claim that the law violates their son’s 14th Amendment right to due process.

In its requirement that school officials immediately place a student suspected of off-campus felonies in alternative education, the law contains no provision for the student to receive notice or a hearing, the judge wrote.

He cited a 1975 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that students facing suspensions of up to 10 days be given at least minimal notice and hearing procedures. In that ruling, Goss v. Lopez, the high court said students have protected property and liberty interests in public education that merit the protection of due process of law.

Judge Nowlin ruled, on a preliminary basis, that the Supreme Court’s standard in that case applies to alternative placements.

“Removal of a student from regular high school classes for placement in alternative education is a form of punishment,” he wrote.

The judge’s ruling concerned some legal experts and state lawmakers, who fear it could lead to more legal challenges to student-discipline decisions.

“We are not denying this young man his constitutional right to a free public education,” said State Rep. Ric Williamson, who helped write the provision. “We are regulating the setting. Due process does not apply to where the child is placed.”

Mr. Nevares’ lawyer disagreed.

Timothy Nevares has been an A and B student who has never been in trouble at school, Mr. Bennett said. Suddenly, without any charges filed, school officials want to place him in a disciplinary program with “all the little badasses,” he said.

“So is that constitutional?” he asked. “Can you punish someone like this based on an accusation alone?”

The Texas Education Agency, the Texas Association of School Boards, and other groups plan to file briefs with Judge Nowlin opposing his preliminary ruling. A final ruling is likely to be several months away.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Science Webinar
Making Science Stick: The Engaging Power of Hands-On Learning
How can you make science class the highlight of your students’ day while
achieving learning outcomes? Find out in this session.
Content provided by LEGO Education
Teaching Profession Webinar Key Insights to Elevate and Inspire Today’s Teachers
Join this free half day virtual event to energize your teaching and cultivate a positive learning experience for students.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Achievement Webinar
Student Success Strategies: Flexibility, Recovery & More
Join us for Student Success Strategies to explore flexibility, credit recovery & more. Learn how districts keep students on track.
Content provided by Pearson

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Climate & Safety Leader To Learn From One Leader’s Plan to Cut Chronic Absenteeism—One Student at a Time
Naomi Tolentino helps educators in Kansas City, Kan., support strong school attendance.
9 min read
Naomi Tolentino Miranda leads a meeting on student attendance at J.C. Harmon High School on Jan. 16, 2025 in Kansas City, Kansas. Tolentino Miranda showed school administrators recent data reflecting positive progress in combating chronic absenteeism.
Naomi Tolentino leads a meeting on student attendance at J.C. Harmon High School on Jan. 16, 2025 in Kansas City, Kansas. Tolentino showed school administrators recent data reflecting positive progress in combating chronic absenteeism.
Erin Woodiel for Education Week
School Climate & Safety Q&A What a 'Positive, Proactive Approach' to Chronic Absenteeism Looks Like
A Kansas City, Kan., leader explains how her district shifted its approach to chronic absenteeism.
6 min read
Naomi Tolentino Miranda walks into J.C. Harmon High School on Jan. 16, 2025 in Kansas City, Kansas. Tolentino Miranda is the Coordinator for Student Support Programs and often visits school administrative teams to check on their progress combating chronic absenteeism among their students.
Naomi Tolentino walks into J.C. Harmon High School on Jan. 16, 2025, in Kansas City, Kan. Tolentino is the coordinator for student support programs and often visits school administrative teams to check on their progress in lowering chronic absenteeism among their students.
Erin Woodiel for Education Week
School Climate & Safety Opinion Schools Can’t Just ‘Return to Normal’ After a Climate Disaster
This is what’s missing when education leaders urge schools to return to normalcy too soon after crises or disasters.
Jaleel R. Howard & Sam Blanchard
5 min read
A jungle gym melted and destroyed by the Eaton Fire is seen at a school, Jan. 15, 2025, in Altadena, Calif.
The Easton Fire melted a jungle gym outside a school in Altadena, Calif.
John Locher/AP
School Climate & Safety Tracker School Shootings This Year: How Many and Where
Education Week is tracking K-12 school shootings in 2025 with injuries or deaths. See the number of incidents and where they occurred.
3 min read
Sign indicating school zone.
iStock/Getty