October 27, 2010
I write with a friendly amendment to Hayes Mizell’s Commentary "The Misuse of Professional Development" (Sept. 22, 1010).
I shed more than a few tears for the kids who weren’t “winners” in the school lotteries filmed in the much-discussed documentary “Waiting For ‘Superman’ ” ("Anticipation and Controversy Surround ‘Superman’ Release", Sept. 1, 2010). But I was even more saddened that the film did not leave me optimistic about any miraculous transformation of America’s schools.
While Barbara Chow’s Commentary "Rigorous and Deeper Learning" (Oct. 6, 2010) was very timely, it raises a troubling issue. Most states that use high-stakes testing for student promotion mainly assess students’ core-content knowledge. If we are to be fair to students, then, as we implement the five concepts that Ms. Chow proposes, our assessments must measure student abilities in all concepts.