Maya Angelou once said, “Do the best you can until you know better. Then, when you know better, do better.” It is time for us to do better! As an organization that grounds its work in the potential of formative assessments, we know firsthand that assessment use has gotten out of control. Our students are bombarded with hours of standardized assessments that feel disconnected from their lives and too often act as gatekeepers, limiting opportunities for their futures. Teachers grapple with the pressure to produce high assessment scores that may not reflect what’s being learned. Administrators drown in a sea of data that offers little practical guidance. As another testing season approaches, a familiar question weighs heavily on our minds: who are these tests serving?
Unfortunately, the answer is none of the above. This isn’t the education system we envisioned. At The Achievement Network (ANet), we believe the current system is a critical instructional, moral, and civil rights issue. We urgently need a better way to assess student progress and target effective support. The pandemic’s impact is undeniable. Students are behind, and equity gaps have widened. This is our most pressing challenge, and tackling the assessment problem is a crucial step.
The Cobra Effect of Misused Assessments
The current assessment landscape in K-12 education suffers from a classic case of the cobra effect. Designed with good intentions – to improve accountability and student learning – the sheer volume and often misaligned nature of these tests have created unintended consequences. Just as the unintended consequence of paying bounties for dead cobras led to their proliferation, the focus on high-stakes testing has driven the creation of a multitude of assessments, each supposedly fulfilling a different need (learning, accountability, prediction). The result? None of these needs are truly met. Teachers, the very people who could leverage this data for targeted instruction, are bogged down in an endless cycle of testing and data analysis. The crux of the issue lies not just in the quantity, but the utility of these assessments. Data often lacks direct instructional relevance, leaving students confused and teachers frustrated.
The Power of Effective Assessment Routines
- At ANet, we’ve been working for nearly two decades alongside schools to codify routines that help teachers leverage assessment data. These routines emphasize:
- Frequent Collaboration: Teachers analyze data together, building a shared understanding of proficient student work, student struggles, and effective interventions.
- Supportive Leadership: School leaders create dedicated time for data analysis and foster a culture of growth, not evaluation.
- High-Quality Assessments: Assessments mirror the rigor of grade level expectations, align with high-quality instructional materials (HQIM) , and provide detailed information about student learning
These routines are more than practices; they’re a cultural shift that prioritizes professional growth and student success. They aren’t just about helping students; they empower educators. Teachers can refine their instruction, and leaders can implement initiatives with a strong foundation that embraces a “never ending cycle of continuous improvement.”
A Better Way: Assessments for Learning
Assessments hold immense potential – not as just data points, but as powerful tools to illuminate student learning. ANet’s work with districts across the country highlights the need for a shift in focus from stakeholder convenience to instructional relevance. We propose a comprehensive approach: a coherent assessment strategy focused on student learning. This means understanding what students know, their misconceptions, and what’s needed to propel them forward. Fewer, better assessments will provide a more positive experience for everyone: students, teachers, and administrators.
Imagine assessments that:
- Align with curriculum: Assessments should measure what’s actually being taught, providing a clear picture of student understanding, pinpointing knowledge gaps and misconceptions.
- Empower teachers: Data should inform instruction, not create fear. Teachers need to feel confident using assessments to tailor their approach to individual student needs.
- Minimize student burden: Fewer, strategic assessments that provide actionable insights are far more valuable than hours spent on generic tests.
- Minimize stress and anxiety: Fostering a low-stakes testing environment encourages learning and growth.
A Call to Action: Realigning Assessments with Student Learning
The current system drowns educators in irrelevant data, eroding trust and hindering true progress. We need a fundamental shift in focus, prioritizing instructional relevance over stakeholder convenience. As educators and policymakers, we must take action. This means rethinking assessment types and frequencies. Do we truly need so many tests? Can technology help us create more efficient and targeted assessments that provide actionable data for teachers? Additionally, ensuring data transparency is crucial. Students and teachers deserve to understand how assessment data is used. This transparency builds trust and empowers educators to utilize the data effectively.
Let’s move beyond viewing assessments as judgment tools and instead see them as opportunities to guide student learning. This means creating a growth mindset where assessments inform instruction and guide students on their individual learning journeys. We can move towards a system that empowers teachers to do their best work in support of their students.
Together, we can transform assessments from a source of stress into a powerful catalyst for growth and discovery. Together, we can do better!
Find out more about Achievement Network!