Opinion
Teacher Preparation Opinion

Ed. Schools Face a Choice: Reform or Fade Away

If schools of education are to be revitalized, it will likely be red states leading the way
By Robert Maranto — October 15, 2024 5 min read
Illustration of a college campus fading away.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

As the Rodney Dangerfields of higher education, education schools get no respect. Back in 1921, using the rough speech of the day, Harvard President Lawrence Lowell described his university’s then-new school of education as “a kitten that ought to be drowned.” Between then and now, few have stepped forward to applaud the institutions.

But with enrollments falling and many policymakers and parents seeking new types of schools, the 2020s and ‘30s could bring opportunities to make schools of education better than they have ever been. Ironically, if the revolution happens, red states are likely to lead the way.

The problems go back more than a century. Yet through most of that time, education school failings were hidden by profound inequities that limited the employment prospects of college-educated women and African Americans: Most teachers had so much talent they succeeded despite poor training, pay, and treatment. The breakdown of very real systems of oppression in job markets has eroded K-12 teaching talent, exposing our failure to prepare educators for classrooms.

Elites could afford to be insensitive to the shortcomings of ed. schools. For example, presidents George H. W. Bush, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, and Joe Biden attended (and typically sent their children to) private schools employing uncertified teachers, most of whom never attended ed. school. The same can be said for presidential nominees Al Gore, John Kerry, and John McCain. (Donald Trump went to private schools, too, but his secondary school was closed, and I could not verify its employ of uncertified teachers when I made phone calls to check.) These school choices reflect distrust of the expertise we education professors claim.

While many academicians disparage schools of education for lacking intellectual rigor, other critics, including former dean of Teachers College, Columbia University, Art Levine criticize us for failing to teach applied skills such as classroom management for teachers and personnel management for leaders. They say we produce too many teachers who misunderstand how children learn and too many leaders without a clue about how to hire, evaluate, coach, and when necessary, terminate teachers.

Nor have we improved equity, the word of the decade in schools of education. As David Marshall and I recently documented, the research out of ed. schools is strangely disconnected from the day-to-day needs of urban principals, focusing more on philosopher of education Paulo Freire than overcoming the COVID-19 attendance drops and learning losses, which devastated low-income communities. As American Public Media reporter Emily Hanford describes in Sold a Story, rock star professors at prominent ed. schools made small fortunes selling ways to teach reading that worsened inequities; for decades, we denied rather than trusted the science.

With enrollments falling and many policymakers and parents seeking new types of schools, the 2020s and ‘30s could bring opportunities to make schools of education better than they have ever been.

But the winds of change are blowing—most strongly from red states. The reflexive red-state distrust of university-based authorities has helped enable many governors and legislatures to remake schooling via new or expanded private and charter schools. (Even under a President Kamala Harris, the federal government seems unlikely to intervene in such changes.) Those new schools will need new systems for training educators. In 20 or more conservative states, this may require that existing education schools either thoroughly reform or fade away.

I see four broad reforms that should happen in all states and could save the schools from obsolescence even as enrollments shift to private and charter schools.

First, we should remake the undergraduate education major to incorporate applied fields with scientifically established knowledge and standards: psychology, biology (to understand child development), and statistics, along with classroom subject-matter knowledge. Such preparation could make new educators both more effective and more respected, justifying more pay.

Second, as more states and cities (including deep-blue New York City) mandate that public schools follow the “science of reading,” it seems phonics have won the reading wars everywhere but in schools of education. Ed. schools that train teachers in practices drawn from the science of reading in accord with state mandates will be well positioned for the 2030s.

See Also

A parent and child looking at 2 different schools
DigitalVision/Getty

Third, our current approaches to civics education, which privilege activism over knowledge and skepticism over patriotism, seem to produce graduates lacking understanding of the rule of law, our 200-plus-year history of peaceful transfers of power (which Trump threatened in 2021), and even NATO (covered by civics standards in just 12 states). For decades, University of Virginia English professor E.D. Hirsch warned that ignorance of history would destroy U.S. democracy, predictions that now seem prescient. Accordingly, ed. schools should partner with organizations like Hirsch’s centrist Core Knowledge Foundation and the conservative Civics Alliance to prepare teachers to prepare citizens.

Finally, we in education schools continue to prepare educators as if there is one (often hazy) best way to educate children. Testifying at a recent congressional committee hearing on teacher preparation, Arizona State University education school dean Carole Basile complained that “our teacher-preparation programs have been designed essentially to mass-produce identical educators. … This tells us a lot about why so many credentialed teachers would rather do something else than teach.” As Jal Mehta and Steven Teles argue in their groundbreaking essay, just as there are differing approaches or “schools” in fields like psychotherapy, elementary and secondary schools with distinct missions need educators with distinct training.

See Also

An elementary school principal sits in a circle of chairs with two students. She holds a clipboard as she waves a finger at a student.
iStock/Getty Images Plus

The growth of charter schools and education savings accounts as de facto vouchers will likely lead to a larger number of smaller schools of choice across red and purple states. Like many schools in Europe, these academies will likely fill specific curricular and pedagogical niches, options very different from the large, bureaucratic, relatively nonacademic traditional public schools that did not serve me or my kids very well and which do even worse for the kids back in my hometown of Baltimore.

When those 100 flowers bloom, their educators will still need preparation. To meet those demands, schools of education should hire professors specializing in specific types of schooling (Montessori, classical, No Excuses, etc.), to prepare teachers and leaders for those missions. Education schools that diversify their faculty in this way will thrive into the 2030s and beyond.

No one likes change. But if we in education schools transform to support reasonable parent and policymaker demands, we can strengthen education rather than deconstruct it.

Related Tags:

Events

School & District Management Webinar Fostering Productive Relationships Between Principals and Teachers
Strong principal-teacher relationships = happier teachers & thriving schools. Join our webinar for practical strategies.
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and K-12 education jubs at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
Promoting Integrity and AI Readiness in High Schools
Learn how to update school academic integrity guidelines and prepare students for the age of AI.
Content provided by Turnitin

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Teacher Preparation Opinion Preservice Teachers Need Better Feedback. Here’s How
In spite of the critical role that they can play in teacher preparation, field supervisors are often overlooked and ignored.
Andrew Kwok
3 min read
Collage illustration of hands sharing lightbulbs.
F. Sheehan/Education Week + Getty Images
Teacher Preparation A Teacher-Prep Conference Warned Against Mentioning DEI. Presenters Pulled Out
Presenters at a national symposium for teacher residencies were asked to affirm they wouldn't violate recent executive orders. Some refused.
6 min read
Illustration of one man speaking into a speech bubbles which shows the letters "DEI" and another man on a ladder painting over the speech bubble as a way to erase it.
Gina Tomko/Education Week + DigitalVision Vectors
Teacher Preparation Trump Administration Slashes Millions in Teacher-Training Grants
Citing "divisive ideology," the U.S. Department of Education cut two programs supporting teacher prep and PD.
8 min read
Signage on the side of the Lyndon B. Johnson Department of Education building in Washington, DC
Greggory DiSalvo/iStock/Getty
Teacher Preparation Some Teacher-Prep Programs Will Prioritize Foundational Math Skills. What It Looks Like
Math knowledge is cumulative, experts say—and mastery of early skills is critical.
4 min read
A illustration of a man in a suit and tie holding a broken chain link and walking toward a woman who is holding the other part of that broken link.
DigitalVision Vectors