Opinion
Social Studies Opinion

The Problem With Primary Sources in Black History Education

Do you know how to put Black history sources in context?
By Abigail Henry — January 30, 2025 | Updated: February 18, 2025 5 min read
A hidden library of knowledge behind the curtain of a classroom.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Updated: This essay was updated to include references to the work of Howard Stevenson and Brittany Jones.

Are you prepared to put a primary source in context when teaching Black histories? I am asking this question because guidance on how teachers should respond to racially charged moments is an overlooked part of teacher training.
One vivid memory from my years teaching 9th grade African American history in Philadelphia comes from the first day of my Abraham Lincoln unit. Students read a 1855 letter from Lincoln to his close friend Joshua Speed. “You know I dislike slavery,” Lincoln wrote, “I also acknowledge your rights and my obligations, under the Constitution, in regard to your slaves. I confess I hate to see the poor creatures hunted down.”
Every year I taught the course, more than one of my Black students squirmed in their chairs and protested, “I’m not a creature!”
I often used this challenging moment as a teaching opportunity by asking my students, “Wait, but he said he hates slavery, isn’t that a good thing? Wait, then again, isn’t referring to Black people as animals racist? What y’all think? Is Lincoln being racist in this jawn or is that just how people talked back then?”
What I did in that moment was start to racially contextualize the source. What do I mean by that? I define “racialized contextualization” as using racial-literacy skills to understand a primary source in its original context. An important part of this context is the problem of primary sources in Black history: While there are valuable archives of Black perspectives throughout American history, the voices that shape our historical record are disproportionately those of powerful white people.

Venn diagram showing the intersections of primary source pitfalls, racial literacy, and contextualization.

Social studies teachers are familiar with contextualization and encouraging students to think like a historian. Indeed, in recent years, I started to keep the Digital Inquiry Group’s Historical Thinking Chart next to my desk. Separated into categories of sourcing, contextualization, corroboration, and close reading, this chart guides teachers on what to consider when using primary sources.

Some teachers, too, are familiar with racial literacy and have the ability to foster productive classroom discussions about race.

What I am interested in is where these two skills—contextualization and racial literacy—meet when using primary sources in teaching Black history specifically. How can we effectively teach Black history when there is a dearth of available primary sources from the Black perspective? How do we discover the undiscovered?

Teachers must explain how the lack of easily accessible primary sources makes it difficult to fully corroborate the primary sources we do have (contextualization) and discuss Black emotions that would possibly exist within the voices missing from our historical archive (racial literacy).
Back in that Philadelphia classroom, I used to ask my students who Lincoln sent that letter to and when. These standard questions about perspective and historical circumstances prompted my students to discuss Lincoln’s overlooked racism and moral compass.
Yet, questions solely around historical thinking never fully led me to where I wanted to take students: the history of power and racism. To racially contextualize Lincoln with accuracy, we need to include the voices of Black people who supported him—and those who did not. (Even Frederick Douglass changed his mind about Lincoln over the course of his life.) I was prepared on how to counter my students’ reaction because of my own regular practice of what Howard Stevenson calls as racial mindfulness.
Black historical contention—the principle that to effectively teach Black history, we must acknowledge conflict within and in-between Black communities—requires that we also teach the voices of everyday Black folk. What was the Black mom at home saying about Lincoln while her husband fought in the Civil War? What did people like Emilie Davis, a free Black woman attending anti-slavery meetings in Philadelphia, think? Most of the time such perspectives have not been preserved, at least not in sources readily available to teachers.
I was recently reminded of the need for this racialized contextualization when designing a lesson plan about the story of Isaac Woodard Jr., a veteran who was beaten blind by a police officer several hours after returning home from World War II.
After spending several hours searching online for primary sources and example lesson plans that included Black perspectives, I discovered that most existing resources included public statements from President Harry Truman and Orson Welles’ radio coverage of the beating at the exclusion of first-person accounts, following the attack.
Teaching these two perspectives alone would not reflect the full picture of what happened after he was beaten, instead shifting the focus of a lesson to the moral concerns of “white saviors” rather than on Isaac Woodard Jr. as a person with his own feelings or on the Black activists who publicized the injustice. Not one of the lesson plans I found online included a source from the perspective of the Black community’s rage or sorrow at the violent trauma. As Brittany Jones describes, these racialized emotions “can also influence how educators teach history and how students engage with and understand history.”
In addition to learning about Black activists and their allies, it is important to me that students learn about how Black folks felt, including Woodward himself, about such an event or how they supported Black men like him. Who taught him to live his life as a blind Black man? Who in the Black community helped him in the next five decades of his life?
These stories of resilience are just as significant as the actions taken by prominent white figures—but they are often missing from the primary sources readily available to teachers. To fully racially contextualize a primary source, teachers should highlight for their students the missing artifacts in Black history. Discussing the imbalance of whose voices were preserved and elevated in history will help Black students express their own emotions today.

Explore the Collection

Read more from educators on advancing Black history education.

Social Studies Opinion What We Lose When We Only Teach ‘Respectable’ Black History
It’s tempting to overcompensate for the absence of Black history by teaching only perfect, pristine, and pure histories.
LaGarrett J. King
5 min read
Many hands build a pyramid of books.
Islenia Mil for Education Week
Social Studies Opinion What We Can All Learn From Black Women in Education
These eight extraordinary women in history have a lot to teach us today.
Dawnavyn M. James
5 min read
A group of children walk across a book under protective hands.
Islenia Mil for Education Week
Social Studies Opinion Can’t Teach AP African American Studies? Start a Club
My students wanted more Black history than our school curriculum offered. Here’s what we did.
Nick Kennedy
3 min read
Student silhouettes walk past a locked library cabinet.
Islenia Mil for Education Week
Social Studies Opinion The Problem With Primary Sources in Black History Education
Do you know how to put Black history sources in context?
Abigail Henry
5 min read
A hidden library of knowledge behind the curtain of a classroom.
Islenia Mil for Education Week
Social Studies Opinion The Three Essentials of Teaching a Black History Class
Launching a new Black history course is a challenge. It should be.
Greg Simmons
4 min read
Papers fall from a hand withholding a pile of papers from students underneath it.
Islenia Mil for Education Week

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Science Webinar
Making Science Stick: The Engaging Power of Hands-On Learning
How can you make science class the highlight of your students’ day while
achieving learning outcomes? Find out in this session.
Content provided by LEGO Education
Teaching Profession Webinar Key Insights to Elevate and Inspire Today’s Teachers
Join this free half day virtual event to energize your teaching and cultivate a positive learning experience for students.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Achievement Webinar
Student Success Strategies: Flexibility, Recovery & More
Join us for Student Success Strategies to explore flexibility, credit recovery & more. Learn how districts keep students on track.
Content provided by Pearson

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Social Studies Opinion Black History to Spark Meaningful Conversations: A Resource List
Here are several books and a film to empower educators to engage with Black history and racial literacy.
Daphanie Bibbs, Dawnavyn M. James & De'Ana Forbes
5 min read
A pile of vibrantly colored reference books.
Dumitru Ochievschi/iStock + Education Week
Social Studies Opinion What Students Have to Say About Their Black History Class
Here’s what made these high school seniors sign up for an African American studies course—and what they’ve learned.
Geoff Wickersham
1 min read
A crowd of abstract multicolored silhouettes of people made in the collage style. A metaphor of unity and partnership.
iStock/Getty images + Education Week
Social Studies This Is How ‘Woke’ Schools Really Are—According to Students
Students don't report evidence of systemic political bias, but do say teachers discuss controversial issues.
5 min read
School Debate 012025 1301863188
DigitalVision Vectors
Social Studies How History Class Can Foster Lifelong Literacy Skills
Parsing historical documents can train students to be critical consumers of information in their own lives, experts say.
3 min read
Words on wooden cubes on a blue background. 3D render. Vector image of a male figure with magnifying glass searching a web window of links.
iStock/Getty