Teaching Q&A

What Teachers Get Wrong About ‘Productive Failure'—and How to Get It Right

By Sarah D. Sparks — September 06, 2024 3 min read
Illustration, concept art of teenager girl struggling with mental health pressures
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Failure can be a student’s best teacher—but only if educators know how to use it.

“In the past, much of how we designed for learning and growth was without failure altogether. Then people started saying, ‘Well, failure can be useful, so when it happens, try to learn from it,’” said Manu Kapur, a professor of learning sciences and higher education at ETH Zurich, a public research university in Switzerland, and the director of the Future Learning Initiative there.

That philosophy has been a key part of inquiry-based and mastery learning models gaining traction in the United States and abroad. But, Kapur said, teachers and materials that don’t guide students through the process of exploring, struggling, and learning don’t improve student performance.

According to a research analysis of 53 studies from around the world, including the United States, letting students engage in problem-solving before instruction in a new concept generally was more effective than the reverse, but instructional design mattered.

Lessons and programs designed around scaffolding how students learned to struggle, problem-solve, and work together—known as “productive failure design"—drove the benefits of delaying direct instruction. Moreover, students in grades 2-5 did not show the same benefit from problem-solving before direct instruction, in large part because instruction in those grades did not tend to incorporate early problem-solving into a systemic process.

See also

Seniors Absadi Kidane, right, and Rafael Rodriguez compare active vs. resting heart rates in a class on anatomy, physiology, and disease at Da Vinci Science High School in Los Angeles.
Seniors Absadi Kidane, right, and Rafael Rodriguez compare active vs. resting heart rates in a class on anatomy, physiology, and disease at Da Vinci Science High School in Los Angeles.
David Walter Banks for Education Week

Kapur, author of the 2024 book Productive Failure: Unlocking Deeper Learning Through the Science of Failure, spoke to Education Week about how teachers can design a classroom that leverages student struggle. The conversation has been edited for length and clarity.

What is productive failure?

Productive failure is not just saying failure can be useful. It’s saying, if failure can be useful for learning and growth, then we shouldn’t wait for it to happen. We should design for it intentionally in a safe way so that we can use it whenever we want it.

What’s different about a classroom designed around productive failure?

This classroom culture is ... based on different sets of norms and expectations. When students are typically given problems to solve, their expectations are, they want to get to the correct answer. In productive failure, we know that you’re not going to be able to get the correct answer, because you haven’t learned the concepts yet.

The expectation is to generate as many ideas as you can to try to solve the problems, and then, to improve your solutions, you work together. So the expectations are more on efforts and growth, rather than getting to the correct answer or solution immediately. The kinds of activities and how students interact and think make a productive failure classroom very different from a regular, direct, and traditional classroom.

What does a lesson designed around productive failure look like?

We are so used to, “Oh, you don’t know something. I will start by teaching you what it is.” That’s direct instruction. But the first aspect of a productive failure classroom is not to start with that.

First, engage students in challenging problem-solving activities where students can generate multiple ideas and solutions—but these activities are designed in a way that students will not be able to get to the correct solutions. They’re intentionally designed for them to get stuck, reach an impasse, in solving the problem. That’s the starting point.

See also

Glowing light bulb among the crumpled papers of failed attempts
iStock/Getty + Education Week
Assessment Opinion ‘Fail Fast, Fail Often’: What a Tech-Bro Mantra Can Teach Us About Grading
Liz MacLauchlan, August 29, 2024
4 min read

Then, once students have done that, that’s when an expert or a teacher comes in, assembles that knowledge, and says, “You know, your solution worked but not fully. And your solution did not work. Here’s why.” Then you have a good discussion, and it assembles into the correct solution or correct way.

What do teachers need to know to use failure effectively?

Teachers need to understand the underlying science—if you use a tool, you need to know why it works—and they need to know how to design using productive failure principles. How do you design these activities? How do you support students? And how do you facilitate that?

Teaching what you know is easy, but teaching based on what students produce is very difficult, right? So that kind of design knowledge is needed.

When we scaled productive failure into the Singapore math curriculum 10 years ago, we trained all the teachers at the [K-12] level in this method and the materials. It takes about two to three years because teachers ... go through their own productive failure path as well.

The first time you try it out, it’s not mental high fidelity; then you get feedback, and you try it again. In my experience, it takes about two to three iterations [for teachers] to get a handle on things.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Science Webinar
Spark Minds, Reignite Students & Teachers: STEM’s Role in Supporting Presence and Engagement
Is your district struggling with chronic absenteeism? Discover how STEM can reignite students' and teachers' passion for learning.
Content provided by Project Lead The Way
Recruitment & Retention Webinar EdRecruiter 2025 Survey Results: The Outlook for Recruitment and Retention
See exclusive findings from EdWeek’s nationwide survey of K-12 job seekers and district HR professionals on recruitment, retention, and job satisfaction. 
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and K-12 education jubs at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Teaching Spotlight Spotlight on PreK-12 Problem-Based Learning
This Spotlight will help you learn how to prepare students for the workforce, partner with students on sustainability initiatives, and more.
Teaching Opinion Student Motivation Is a Perennial Concern. What Are We Missing?
Even if we want to achieve a goal, there are reasons why we don't. This can explain what's happening with students.
5 min read
Conceptual illustration of classroom conversations and fragmented education elements coming together to form a cohesive picture of a book of classroom knowledge.
Sonia Pulido for Education Week
Teaching Opinion Advice From Over 1,200 Experienced Educators at Your Fingertips
Need help with using AI in the classroom? How about teaching students to write? Or fostering relationships? Plenty is available here.
1 min read
Conceptual illustration of classroom conversations and fragmented education elements coming together to form a cohesive picture of a book of classroom knowledge.
Sonia Pulido for Education Week
Teaching Tips for Easing Students Back Into Routines After Winter Break
Educators on social media shared their insights on how they resume class following the winter break.
2 min read
Buses parked covered with snow
iStock/Getty